fbpx
Free, no-obligation initial consultation available.

Civil Litigation Lawyer Adelaide | Dispute Resolution

Civil Litigation is a broad term that describes a court based legal dispute under the common law system which is not related to criminal liability. Civil litigation is defined by the fact that there are two opposing parties, be they private individuals or businesses, who are in dispute about a set of facts or the application of the law to a particular set of facts.
Some of the common types of civil proceedings Scammell & Co can assist with include:

  • commercial disputes over contracts and leases;
  • mortgage default claims;
  • property disputes;
  • negligence claims (for example, involving personal injury or property damage);
  • claims in relation to deceased estates; and
  • insolvency disputes

So how does the civil litigation process work?

In the common law system, there is a judge who presides over the dispute and the opposing parties bring submissions and evidence in support of their claims to a particular position on the matter before the court. The court can make rulings on what evidence is admissible based on the laws of evidence which is usually derived partly from statute and partly from the common law in relation to what is admissible evidence or otherwise. Once the judge has heard all evidence in relation to the case, they can then make a determination on the facts of the matter and apply the law in relation to the dispute. Part of the system of civil litigation also involves the appeals process. If a party is aggrieved by a decision, it may usually make an appeal because the lower court made an error of law. As cases trickle up the chain of appeal courts, they tend to involve matters of more weighty significance in terms of the law. A case in the High Court, for instance can influence the whole direction of a particular area of law.

How can Scammell & Co help resolve my dispute?

Whether representing the plaintiff or the defendant in civil or criminal proceedings, a Scammell & Co lawyer manages all stages of the dispute resolution process. These include:

  • Investigation
  • Pleadings
  • Discovery
  • Mediation
  • Pre-trial motions
  • Trial
  • Appeal

The number of stages a case reaches depends on the willingness for each side to resolve the matter.
Irrespective of which side of the dispute you find yourself, a Scammell & Co dispute resolution lawyer will support you through the process. This includes:

  • providing legal advice and workable options to protect your interests;
  • handling negotiations;
  • conducting mediation; and if all else fails
  • representing you before a relevant court.

A Scammell & Co lawyer has the experience to safeguard your rights and resolve disputes as quickly and amicably as possible to avoid you incurring further losses.

An experienced Scammell & Co. civil litigation lawyer has a comprehensive command of the civil litigation and dispute resolution process, and their advice and guidance to clients will take into consideration all relevant factors which will assist in:

  1. Preparing a claim against a Defendant; or
  2. Defending against a Plaintiff’s claim.

Following is a step-by-step overview of the litigation process. The stages of litigation may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Also, settlement can occur at any time during the dispute resolution process, even after trial.

Flow chart showing the litigation process

Click on the relevant term below for an explanation.

Notice of Action

The Notice is a formal and detailed letter sent by the person or company who wishes to bring a claim (usually called the Plaintiff) to the person or company that they wish to claim against (usually called the Defendant).

The Notice sets out what the claim is, for example a claim for money owed or property to be returned. The Notice also states the Plaintiff’s intention to take the matter to court.

The Plaintiff must usually wait from 21 to 90 days after sending the Notice before proceeding to the next step in the litigation process, (step 2 below). Many disputes settle in this time, avoiding the cost and delay of going to court.

Summons / Application

This is the document filed in court to start proceedings on behalf of the person or company who wishes to bring a claim (usually called the Plaintiff). There may of course be more than one Plaintiff (and also more than one Defendant.)

It must be issued out of an appropriate court which has jurisdiction to deal with the matter described in the summons.

It will be addressed to the person against whom the claim is brought. (The Defendant) It will usually be accompanied by a document known as a ‘Statement of Claim’. A statement of claim sets out in some detail why the Plaintiff is bringing the claim and what orders the Plaintiff is asking the court to make.

Service

After the summons has been filed in court, it will be sealed by the court and usually returned to the plaintiff to arrange service on the party to whom the summons is addressed (the Defendant).

In some cases the summons must be personally served on the Defendant. In other cases it is sufficient to send it to the Defendant’s address.

Defence / Counterclaim

After a Defendant has received a summons he / she or the company is allowed a period (usually 21 days) in which to file a Defence. That is a document setting out why he /she does not agree that the claim should proceed.

The statement of claim and the defence when read together enable the court to know what it is that the parties are arguing about, and to have some idea of what evidence will be presented if the matter goes to trial.

Both the statement of claim and the defence are important documents which must be very precisely prepared.

A party would not normally be allowed to present evidence in court that is outside the matters identified in the statement of claim and/or the defence.

If the Defendant does not file a defence then after the time limit (usually 21 days) has elapsed the Plaintiff may ask the court to issue a ‘default’ judgment against the Defendant.

Discovery / Disclosure

As part of the preparation of a case for trial both parties are required to provide a list of the documents which are in their possession, which may have any relevance to the matters coming before the Court. Such a list must be exhaustive and must not hide anything.

This discovery, in many cases, may only be 20 or 30 pages, but in other cases can be thousands of pages.

Interrogatories

In some cases the parties may file written questions in court requiring answers by the other side before the matter proceeds to trial.

Notice to Admit

Parties to a case can, if they so wish, file a document on the other side requiring the other side to admit certain facts or documents and, in effect, say that those matters which are admitted do not need to be dealt with by formal evidence at the trial. This can sometimes save time and expense at the trial.

Directions and Hearings

Once a defence has been filed the court will nominate a time when the parties must come to the court and discuss before a judge the preparation of the matter for trial. These are usually five or ten minute hearings and may be adjourned for a period to allow certain steps to be taken before coming back before the judge to be again considered.

A matter will not be allowed to go into the trial list until the judge is satisfied that both sides have adequately prepared their evidence for presentation to the court.

Pre-Trial Conference

Before the matter goes to trial the Court will normally direct the parties to attend before the judge in person with their solicitors. The judge will discuss with the solicitors and the parties whether the matter can be settled without needing to go to trial. This is known as a pre-trial conference.

Listing Conference

Finally, if the matter does not settle, it will be sent by the Court to a listing conference which will be attended by the solicitors on both sides. The court will fix a date that suits the court, the solicitors and barristers on both sides, the parties and the witnesses.

For this conference it is necessary to make an estimate of how long the trial will take and to discuss any special arrangements for witnesses that may be coming from interstate or overseas.

Trial

The great majority of matters are settled before any trial occurs; less than 1% actually proceed to trial. The 1% which do go to trial are those where both sides strongly believe they will win. Half of them are wrong. All litigation is risky.

Those matters that do proceed to trial must wait their turn in the court’s trial list which can often mean waiting for many months or even up to a year.

After hearing the evidence of a trial, a judge may give a judgment straight away or may wish to consider the matter further before giving a decision. This can also, on some occasions, result in further delays of several months.

Appeal

A party who is not satisfied with the judge’s decision may, on some occasions, be able to appeal to a higher court to have the decision of the judge in the lower court reviewed.

Execution

Once a court has made a final order, whether it be after a trial, by a default judgment or after an appeal, the party who is successful is then entitled to enforce the judgment (which usually includes an order for payment of that party’s legal costs by the other side). Enforcement can take many forms including seizure of property, summons to appear in the debtors court and/or bankruptcy.

Mediation

On some occasions with the consent of both parties, the Court can direct that the matter go to mediation in an attempt to settle it before it goes to trial. This means something similar to a settlement conference but is much more in depth and may take anything from half a day up to several days. A mediator who is usually a qualified barrister or a judge can make recommendations to the parties as to how the matter should be settled but cannot make any actual orders.

Third Party Proceeding

On some occasions a Defendant may say that he is entitled to be indemnified by a third party in respect of the matters claimed against him by the Plaintiff. In that event the Defendant will issue what is known as a third party notice and which is in effect a cross-summons to bring in a third, fourth or fifth party.

Contribution Notices

Where there is more than one Defendant in an action the Defendants may seek orders from the court as to the proportions in which any liability they may have to the Plaintiff should be adjusted between the Defendants. This is done by filing a contribution notice which again is something like a cross-summons against each other.

Filed Offer

Where a Defendant admits part of a claim but denies another part they may file an offer for that part of the claim which they admit. For example, a Defendant might be sued for $50,000 and say that they admit $15,000 only. They can then file an offer for $15,000 plus costs up to the date of the filed offer and defend the balance of the claim.

Should the trial proceed and the Plaintiff only get an order for $15,000, the Defendant, in effect, wins the matter on costs because he can say to the court “I was always willing to pay that amount and there was no need to have a trial”. This shifts the costs risk onto the Plaintiff.

Until the trial is over the judge is not aware of the filed offer. Either party can file offers from time to time with differing costs benefits.

Costs

Generally speaking a successful party in an action is awarded costs against the other party (which are usually much less than the actual legal costs incurred).

Time Limits

It is important that if you have a claim that you do not delay in pursuing it.

If your claim is for personal injury, the law says that you must begin the litigation process outlined above within three years.

If your claim is under contract or relates to property damage, you usually have six years in which to begin the litigation process outlined above.

If that time has passed, only in exceptional circumstances will the court allow you to enter into litigation to try to recover your claim.

Email Us
close slider

    Online Enquiry

    Contact Scammell & Co. online by completing the form below. Please note that fields marked with an asterisk (*) must be completed to ensure a prompt response.